Spectra S1 vs S2 Which One Is The Better Option For You

Choosing the right breast pump to suit your needs and lifestyle can be sometimes overwhelming. So let’s say, you already narrowed down the choices to which brand you want to buy.

Spectra S1 vs S2

Now the next step is to pick the model because more often than not, there’s still a wide array of options available for you.

Moreover, one of the perfect examples here is Spectra S1 VS S2. What's the difference between the two? Which one is better?

Are they the same and the other is nothing more than an upgrade? Are there additional features which can make life easier for a breastfeeding mum?

More...

Spectra S1

  PROS

  • thumbs-o-up
    Closed system
  • thumbs-o-up
    Quiet and doesn’t emit a loud sound while pumping
  • thumbs-o-up
    Adjustable suction – strong, powerful and efficient
  • thumbs-o-up
    Hospital grade
  • thumbs-o-up
    With rechargeable battery

  CONS   

  • thumbs-o-down
    Battery may break down with harsh usage
  • thumbs-o-down
    The flanges can come off quickly
  • thumbs-o-down
    Prone to spills
Spectra S2

   PROS

  • thumbs-o-up
    Closed system
  • thumbs-o-up
    Can be used as a single or double pump
  • thumbs-o-up
    Nearly silent
  • thumbs-o-up
    Has a digital display – allows you more control over the speed and rhythm
  • thumbs-o-up
    Includes two 24mm and two 28mm flanges
  • thumbs-o-up
    Lightweight

   CONS

  • thumbs-o-down
    No rechargeable battery, the only power option is thru an AC adapter
  • thumbs-o-down
    The only color is pink

What Makes The Spectra S1 Better?

Spectra S1 vs Spectra S2


To be honest, there's not much difference between the two. So we will just list down and expound on the products' features.

  It is portable.

 That is the main selling point because if anyone asks me to name one thing that the S1 has that the S2 does not, this would be it

It would come in handy for those who prefer pumping on-the-go or those who want something they can bring during travels

It may not seem like much from the get-go, but sometimes, it can be a real lifesaver if you do not have any access to power. You have enough freedom to pump in the car or between breaks at work.

   

The suction is efficient

  Any breast pump that pumps out more milk with less time always gets a good grade in my book.

Also, the fact that the suction almost feels like it is the baby sucking, that helps increase your milk supply. Some mothers complain about those low quality and inefficient products which, instead of helping them, affects their availability in a bad way.

A good pump will help you produce more and not less.

 It is comfortable and quiet

 Because you have control over the speed and rhythm, you can adjust according to your level of comfort.

If you cannot take a strong suction, that is fine. Also, while it is not completely silent, it is still relatively quieter than other brands. It can be a problem if you are pumping in the same room as your sleeping child.

The closed system ensures that there’s no contact between the milk and the motor

In short, it is hygienic and protects your breast milk from exposure to mold or bacteria.

In fact, you will not find any milk in the tubing unless of course, there are issues with your Spectra S1. Also, this makes cleaning easy.

What Makes The Spectra S2 Better?

Spectra S1 vs S2

 It has a powerful suction. Spectra may be new to the game, but they sure know how to step it up and compete with other more popular brands. The overall performance is incredible but what's more impressive is even with excellent power, it is still gentle. That is hard to accomplish, to be honest.

With the silicon cushion inserts, pumping makes it not just convenient but also comfortable for the mother – no unnecessary stress for her. It even has a timer and a night light to ensure maximum comfort.

heart

​It has a powerful suction. 

Spectra may be new to the game, but they sure know how to step it up and compete with other more popular brands.

The overall performance is incredible but what's more impressive is even with excellent power, it is still gentle. That is hard to accomplish, to be honest.

With the silicon cushion inserts, pumping makes it not just convenient but also comfortable for the mother – no unnecessary stress for her. It even has a timer and a night light to ensure maximum comfort.


star

It holds up well.

Durability is always a priority when it comes to breast pumps. It is one of those things where finding something cheap makes you skeptical.

You do not pump once a day; you do it several times daily. Thus, you need a product that can meet all your demands.

So for its price point, it definitely won't break the bank. Still, you get your money's worth and more.

cog

 The closed system will not expose your milk.

Those who have used other breast pumps always fear that some of the breast milk might enter the parts which you cannot clean – like the tubes.

With the Spectra S2, no such thing will happen. You can put your mind at ease that the liquid gold will stay where it is supposed to, so no problem with mold or bacteria is accidentally tainting it.


pencil

It is easy to use and efficient

 Setting up and using it is foolproof and since it operates quietly, you will not be bothered if you use it in public places or even at work.

That is often the biggest downfall of other products – they are too loud, or they make annoying sounds as you pump. You will not encounter such issues with the S2. Moreover, it feels natural too!


The Winner Is…


Spectra S1 vs S2

To be fair, it depends on your needs. However, for me, I would go for the Spectra S1 for the sole reason of portability.

You will never know when you need to pump, so it is always better to stay prepared. Sometimes, there's no power available anywhere, or you just want the freedom to pump away from sockets – like when you are pumping in bed.

This little feature makes a huge difference if you ask me. However, of course, if that does not bother you and you do not mind the lack of battery option, S2 is just as good regarding power and performance.

Nancy Shaw
 

Hi. My name is Nancy. I am a nurse by profession and a writer by passion and ever since I became a mother, I’ve become very active in sharing useful and important information about basically anything under the sun and a full-time mother to a 21-month old boy. Read more about me here.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: